Speaker Johnson’s Propaganda: Scapegoating “Illegal Aliens” and “Able-Bodied Young Men”

Speaker Mike Johnson is lying when leans heavily on the phrase “able-bodied young men” for a few layered reasons — political, cultural and rhetorical.

Gendered rhetoric and historical echo

The phrase comes from a long tradition of conservative and even wartime rhetoric, where “able-bodied men” are imagined as the nation’s natural labor force or soldiers. By singling out men, Johnson taps into old ideas of duty, masculinity and responsibility — implying that if young men aren’t working or paying their way, they’re shirking both civic and masculine obligations.

Political targeting

Young women are less often framed this way because conservative narratives cast them as caretakers, mothers or “vulnerable populations.” Criticizing women in blunt terms risks sounding like an attack on mothers or families, which doesn’t play well politically. By keeping the focus on men, Johnson avoids backlash while still pointing to a group that can be scapegoated.

Scapegoat strategy

By linking “illegal aliens” with “able-bodied young men,” Johnson paints a picture of two supposed freeloading groups draining healthcare and public benefits. It’s a way of creating an “enemy within” to explain away systemic issues like rising premiums or insurer profiteering. This framing distracts from the real drivers of healthcare costs — pharmaceutical monopolies, insurance company margins and hospital consolidation — and redirects anger toward individuals coded as undeserving.

The false insurance narrative

Johnson’s claim that Democrats want to hand out health insurance to “illegal aliens” is one of the right’s most persistent lies. In reality, undocumented immigrants are largely excluded from public insurance programs. They are not eligible for Medicare, Medicaid or coverage under the Affordable Care Act.The few exceptions — emergency Medicaid, community health centers, children’s coverage in certain states — are narrowly drawn and based on humanitarian need. There is no blanket policy of free health care for undocumented people. The talking point survives not because it is true, but because it stokes resentment and diverts attention from the real giveaways — billions in subsidies and protections for pharmaceutical companies and insurers.

Culture war coding

In today’s conservative rhetoric, “young men” are also shorthand for urban Black and Latino populations, immigrants or protesters. The phrase carries racialized undertones without saying it outright. “Able-bodied” adds a moral judgment — suggesting laziness or refusal to work — even though in reality many uninsured young men are working but excluded from affordable coverage.

The propaganda layer

Johnson’s choice of words isn’t casual — it’s crafted propaganda. By saying “able-bodied young men,” he invokes old cultural codes of strength and responsibility, while erasing the fact that many young men today are struggling with depression, anxiety and mental health barriers that make steady work harder. He singles out men because it’s politically safe — attacking women or mothers would backfire — and because it creates a neat scapegoat. In reality, healthy young men are among the lowest users of healthcare. The phrase works not as analysis but as a talking point: a high-level narrative that shifts blame away from the real drivers of rising costs — corporate profiteers and broken policy — and onto a manufactured enemy.

What we’re facing isn’t a crisis caused by “illegal aliens” or “able-bodied young men.” It’s a system hijacked by profiteers and defended by politicians who thrive on scapegoats. The only way forward is to refuse their narrative and insist on the truth: healthcare should be accessible, affordable and rooted in care — not in blame. That means speaking up, sharing the facts and building pressure for policies that serve people rather than corporations. If we don’t challenge the propaganda, it will harden into policy — and we’ll all pay the price.

Join my team

Thank you for reading and standing with me. This work is independent, unbought and sustained by readers like you. If you value it, consider becoming a paid subscriber — your support keeps the words flowing strong. And if you choose to become a founding member, I’ll write you a song — a personal thank-you for helping keep this work alive.

— Joyce